Sheetz MexAmerican menu

Quesadillas, tacos, burrito bowls and nachos from the MexAmerican screen, with prices, calories and ways to lighten them up.

Reviewed October 2026By the Sheetz Menu Hub editorial team
About these numbers: prices and nutrition are our estimates, last reviewed October 2026. Sheetz prices change by store and state, so check the Sheetz app before you order.

Sheetz MexAmerican prices

MexAmerican items cost $5.49 to $7.99. Quesadillas come grilled with cheese and your choice of steak, chicken or just cheese. Bowls and nachos are built like burritos without the tortilla.

Sheetz MexAmerican items
ItemPriceCaloriesProteinSodiumContains
Steak Quesadilla$7.4981044 g1,880 mgMilk, Wheat, Soy
Chicken Quesadilla$7.2978046 g1,810 mgMilk, Wheat, Soy
Cheese QuesadillaVeg$5.9969028 g1,460 mgMilk, Wheat, Soy
Beef Tacos (3)Value$5.4962028 g1,240 mgMilk, Wheat, Soy
Grande Burrito BowlNo gluten ingr.$7.4961038 g1,690 mgMilk
Stuffed NachosNo gluten ingr.$5.7969022 g1,520 mgMilk, Soy
Grande Quesarito$7.9992040 g2,140 mgMilk, Wheat, Soy

Quesadillas

The Steak Quesadilla and Chicken Quesadilla are the best sellers in this section. Both land around 800 calories because of the cheese and the large tortilla. Add pico, jalapenos and lettuce for free, and guacamole or sour cream for a small charge.

Grande Quesarito

The Quesarito is a burrito wrapped in a cheese quesadilla instead of a plain tortilla. It's the biggest item in the section at about 920 calories, and it's easy to split between two people.

Lighter and gluten-free picks

The Grande Burrito Bowl skips the tortilla entirely, so it has no wheat ingredients and about 58 g of carbs. The Stuffed Nachos use corn chips. Both are on our gluten-free list, with the usual warning that the kitchen isn't gluten-free.

Tacos

Three beef tacos cost about $5.49. They're crunchy or soft depending on the store and the season, and they're one of the best values in the section.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Sheetz Quesarito?

A Quesarito is a burrito filled with meat, rice, beans, cheese and toppings, wrapped inside a grilled cheese quesadilla.

Does Sheetz have tacos all year?

Taco availability changes. Some stores carry them year-round and others run them as a limited-time item. Check the MexAmerican screen in the app.

What's the healthiest MexAmerican item?

The Grande Burrito Bowl with chicken, extra veggies and salsa instead of queso is the lightest full meal in the section.